The world of professional wrestling is a relentless, dynamic spectacle, a kaleidoscope of athleticism, character, and storytelling that unfolds across continents and broadcasting platforms. Every week, athletes push boundaries, narratives twist and turn, and new legends are forged, or existing ones reaffirmed. In this vibrant, often chaotic environment, the voice of the fan serves as the ultimate arbiter, shaping perceptions and anointing those who truly capture the imagination. It is within this spirit of passionate discourse that a unique, community-driven initiative thrives: a comprehensive ranking system designed to identify the standout performers who have most captivated audiences during a given seven-day period. This endeavor culminates in the prestigious annual Performer of the Year accolade, affectionately known as the Cageside Cup, a testament to sustained excellence and audience connection throughout a demanding wrestling calendar.
As the professional wrestling circuit barrels through the depths of January 2026, the competitive landscape for the Cageside Cup remains as hotly contested as ever. We stand at a pivotal juncture, reflecting on the dominant forces of the past week while simultaneously looking ahead to the upcoming slate of events that will undoubtedly reshape the ongoing narrative. The voting from the week encompassing January 11th through January 17th, 2026, has just concluded, offering a fascinating snapshot of fan sentiment and highlighting the individuals who delivered the most compelling performances across the global stage. These weekly polls are not merely popularity contests; they are a nuanced reflection of in-ring prowess, character development, promo ability, and overall impact on a promotion’s narrative, meticulously compiled by a dedicated collective of wrestling enthusiasts who dissect every nuance of the squared circle. The outcome of these regular assessments not only celebrates immediate triumphs but also contributes to the cumulative point tally for the coveted year-end Cageside Cup, a race that will not conclude until April.
Leading the charge for the most recent ranking period, claiming the coveted number one spot, is none other than the powerhouse from TNA Wrestling, Mike Santana. His ascent to the top is a story of resilience, reinvention, and undeniable talent. Santana’s journey through the wrestling world has been marked by a consistent display of explosive offense and an inherent intensity that makes him a captivating presence. For years, he carved out a formidable reputation as one half of one of the most acclaimed tag teams in recent memory, captivating audiences with his dynamic partnership and synchronized brutality. However, a significant shift in his career trajectory saw him embark on a revitalized singles run, a path that has now culminated in a monumental achievement. The week in question saw Santana solidify his status as a main event player, capturing the TNA World Championship for a second time. This victory wasn’t just another title change; it represented the culmination of a deeply personal and physically demanding quest, signaling his complete re-establishment at the pinnacle of the organization. His performances during this period undoubtedly showcased the full spectrum of his abilities, from his raw power and agility inside the ring to the emotional resonance of his championship pursuit, solidifying his position as the top fan choice for that specific week.
Following closely behind Santana, securing the number two position, is a man who has consistently proven himself to be "Him" within WWE’s developmental brand, NXT: Carmelo Hayes. Hayes has been a foundational pillar of NXT’s recent success, embodying a new generation of talent with an unparalleled swagger and an almost innate ability to deliver under pressure. His reign as NXT Champion was widely lauded, characterized by a series of high-stakes encounters and a masterful blend of cocky confidence and legitimate in-ring skill. Even without gold around his waist, Hayes remains a central figure, consistently delivering memorable segments and thrilling matches that keep the NXT universe invested. His unique blend of athleticism, sharp promo delivery, and a keen understanding of character psychology ensures that he is always a candidate for top honors in any fan-driven ranking. His continued presence near the top of these weekly polls is a testament to his consistent ability to grab headlines and elevate the standard of performance on Tuesday nights, demonstrating that his star power transcends any particular championship reign.
The third position in the rankings features a compelling tie, illustrating the diverse appeal and undeniable impact of two distinct personalities: Toni Storm from All Elite Wrestling and Trick Williams, another shining star from NXT. Toni Storm has carved out an incredibly unique niche for herself within AEW, evolving her character into the "Timeless" Toni Storm – a glamorous, somewhat anachronistic Hollywood starlet whose dramatic antics are matched only by her ferocious in-ring capabilities. Her character work is a masterclass in theatricality and comedic timing, yet she never fails to remind audiences of her pedigree as a former world champion and a formidable competitor. Her performances during the voting period likely blended her signature blend of captivating character vignettes with strong in-ring showings, proving that she is as much an entertainer as she is an athlete. Sharing the third spot, Trick Williams has enjoyed an absolutely breakout year in NXT. Originally known as Carmelo Hayes’ enforcer and confidante, Williams has successfully stepped out of his tag partner’s shadow, developing a genuine connection with the audience and showcasing an impressive growth in all facets of his game. His infectious charisma, improved in-ring work, and a catchphrase that has resonated deeply with the NXT faithful ("Whoop That Trick!") have made him one of the brand’s most exciting prospects. His strong showing in the rankings reflects the palpable buzz surrounding his rapid ascent and the anticipation of what he will achieve next, particularly as the possibility of a rivalry with Hayes looms large.
The diversity of talent recognized in these rankings continues with "Hangman" Adam Page landing at number five. A former AEW World Champion, Page holds a special place in the hearts of wrestling fans due to his deeply personal and often emotionally charged storylines. His journey from reluctant hero to world champion, battling personal demons and external adversaries, resonated with a vast audience. Even when not holding a championship, Page consistently delivers high-quality matches and contributes significantly to AEW’s intricate narrative tapestry. His inclusion in the top five speaks to his consistent drawing power and the unwavering connection he maintains with his fanbase, who appreciate his authentic character and hard-hitting style. Whether he’s in a main event feud or a compelling mid-card story, Page’s presence is always felt, and his performances are regularly among the most talked-about.
The international flavor of modern wrestling is beautifully showcased by the presence of Mike Bailey at number six and Kevin Knight at number seven. Mike "Speedball" Bailey is a globally recognized talent, renowned for his breathtakingly innovative offensive style and incredible athleticism. His high-octane performances, often blending martial arts strikes with gravity-defying maneuvers, have made him a fan favorite wherever he competes, particularly within Impact Wrestling where he has been a consistent highlight. His ability to deliver exhilarating contests week after week ensures he remains a prominent figure in any discussion of top performers. Kevin Knight, representing New Japan Pro-Wrestling, has steadily risen through the ranks, evolving from a promising Young Lion into a formidable competitor. His athleticism and technical proficiency, honed through the rigorous NJPW dojo system, have made him a standout in the junior heavyweight division. His tag team work, notably as part of Catch 2/2, has earned him accolades, and his continued development suggests a bright future. His ranking indicates a growing international appreciation for his craft and the quality of his recent outings.
Rounding out the top ten are three more distinct and impactful figures: Gunther at number eight, Lei Ying Lee at number nine, and a tie between Hazuki and Sami Zayn at number ten. Gunther, the "Ring General" of WWE, has redefined the Intercontinental Championship, elevating its prestige through a historically dominant reign characterized by brutal, physical encounters and an unwavering aura of superiority. His matches are always hard-hitting spectacles, and his consistent delivery of main event-caliber performances makes him a perennial contender in any fan-voted ranking. Lei Ying Lee’s appearance at number nine highlights the growing appreciation for joshi wrestling and the exceptional talent coming out of promotions like Stardom and Tokyo Joshi Pro-Wrestling. Her unique style and captivating performances have clearly resonated with a global audience, demonstrating the far-reaching influence of high-quality wrestling regardless of origin. Finally, the tie at number ten features Hazuki, another standout from the vibrant Japanese women’s wrestling scene, known for her aggressive style and fierce intensity. Her consistent contributions to Stardom’s dynamic roster have solidified her reputation as a top-tier performer. Sharing the spot is WWE’s Sami Zayn, an enduring fan favorite whose incredible ability to connect with an audience, whether as a sympathetic underdog or a comedic foil, is virtually unmatched. His recent storylines have consistently showcased his versatility, emotional depth, and ability to elevate any segment or feud he is a part of, cementing his status as one of the most beloved figures in modern wrestling.
These weekly rankings are more than just a momentary snapshot; they are integral components of a larger, year-long narrative culminating in the awarding of the Cageside Cup. Points accumulated each week contribute to an overall leaderboard, tracking who maintains consistent excellence throughout the season. The current standings for the Cageside Cup, reflecting all voting through the week ending January 17th, show significant movement for the first time in several weeks. The competitive landscape is tightening, and while some individuals have maintained their stronghold, the recent surge from performers like Santana, Hayes, Storm, and Williams has injected new energy into the race. This shift indicates that the battle for Performer of the Year is far from decided, with many months of captivating wrestling still to unfold before next April’s grand announcement. With major events on the horizon, such as the highly anticipated Royal Rumble in the WWE calendar, the coming weeks are poised to be critical for those looking to make a significant push in the overall standings. The drama of the annual competition mirrors the unpredictability of wrestling itself, where a single match or a pivotal storyline development can dramatically alter a performer’s trajectory and fan perception.
As the wrestling world never stops, neither does the opportunity for fans to make their voices heard. The polls are now open for the next iteration of the rankings, covering all nationally televised and internet streaming professional wrestling shows that took place between January 18th and January 24th, 2026. This extensive list includes flagship programs such as WWE’s Raw and SmackDown, alongside the dynamic offerings of NXT, and the independent flavor of Evolve. From All Elite Wrestling, fans will be considering performances from Dynamite and Collision, while Impact Wrestling’s weekly show and Ring of Honor’s ROH on HonorClub also feature prominently. The global reach extends to New Japan Pro-Wrestling’s Saturday Night’s Main Event, and the vibrant Lucha Libre scene with CMLL and AAA’s weekend presentations, ensuring that no stone is left unturned in the quest to identify the week’s most impactful talents.
Participating in these community rankings is straightforward, designed to encourage broad engagement and diverse perspectives. Each ballot allows for five distinct selections, enabling fans to highlight their top five performers who most impressed or entertained them during the specified week. While the same individual cannot occupy multiple spots on a single ballot, the flexibility exists to split a single or multiple spots between different wrestlers if their impact was deemed equally significant. This system empowers every fan to contribute their unique insights, collectively shaping a dynamic and authentic reflection of the current wrestling landscape. The power of the wrestling community lies in its collective passion and discerning eye, and it is through this shared endeavor that the true pulse of the industry is measured. We eagerly await your ballots and look forward to revealing the next set of results, further charting the course of the ongoing race for the Cageside Cup and celebrating the incredible talent that defines professional wrestling in 2026.
